Back to RJ Archive

Double Jeopardy: The Modern Dilemma for Juvenile Justice

Anderson, Christina L
June 4, 2015

Source: (2004) University of Pennsylvania Law Review. 152(3): 1181-1219.

This Comment evaluates and exposes the realities of inflexible penalties for youth as well as unearths the spectrum of equitable alternatives to the “get-toughâ€? model. To begin the exploration of this continuum, Part I focuses on the existing disciplinary system in the majority of states. Section A supplies a recent chronology of the zero-tolerance movement in schools and discusses the socio-political and legal factors which surround the zealous retributive trend. Section B examines the realities of school crime, questioning the appropriateness of mandatory suspension/expulsion measures in addressing the daily deviance of young students.
Part II then focuses on the simultaneous upsurge in the imposition of formal sanctions by the juvenile justice system. Sections A and B assess how the disciplinary goals and tactics of educational facilities have begun to overlap with those of the juvenile justice system, creating a type of “dual enforcementâ€? wherein the institutions share information, authority, and social functions. Section C documents the social and legal entrenchment of this pervasive, punitive mentality. Part III, however, identifies a reasonable alternative to such hardnosed, retributive recourse: restorative justice. Section A first explains the general restorative theory, next references particular models for the implementation of restorative justice, and lastly, offers examples of successful, real-world applications. Section B details the benefits of supplementing harsh punishments with a more individualized and integrative forum. After summarizing the administrative, social, and personal advantages incurred through restorative justice practices, Section B concludes with an emphasis on the critical potential for reintegration generated by such mechanisms and a report on restorative justice’s recent success. (excerpt)


Support the cause

We've Been Restoring Justice for More Than 40 Years

Your donation helps Prison Fellowship International repair the harm caused by crime by emphasizing accountability, forgiveness, and making amends for prisoners and those affected by their actions. When victims, offenders, and community members meet to decide how to do that, the results are transformational.

Donate Now