Back to RJ Archive

Seeking forgiveness key in many faiths

June 15, 2009

From Steven Spearie’s article in  Pope John Paul might have been subscribing to the most basic, but
hardly the easiest, of Christian mandates: If you want to be right with
God, you have to forgive others.

Religious leaders and others say forgiveness is within reach, even for those convicted of horrific crimes.

Last month, former football star Michael Vick was released from federal
prison (he’s under home confinement until mid-July) after serving the
majority of his 23-month term on federal dogfighting conspiracy charges.

The dogfighting charges, and reports that dogs were treated inhumanely
— even killed if they fought poorly — shocked the nation and
indefinitely drummed Vick out of the National Football League, where he
was an All-Pro quarterback for the Atlanta Falcons.

But his release from prison brought to light questions of redemption and forgiveness.

Before entering prison in August 2007, Vick publicly said he “found
Jesus and I asked him for forgiveness and I’d just turned my life over
to God.” Media reports state Vick’s high school football coach
acknowledged the ex-star is a changed man because of the prison
experience, and that Vick has also met with former NFL head coach Tony
Dungy, who is involved with Fellowship of Christian Athletes and with
the Prison Crusade Ministry.

The Rev. Roy Newman, senior pastor of Fresh Visions Community Church in
Springfield, Ill., says Vick has completed his prison time, and
whatever skills allow him to succeed in society, “so well for Michael

“One can be restored,” Newman says. “It’s not for me to look at that person in condemnation.”

As for redemption, that’s a matter of God’s judgment, says the Rev.
Richard Chiola, pastor of St. Frances Cabrini Catholic Church in

Chiola says Vick can be “re-socialized” by reforming his way of seeing
his own social position, asking for forgiveness and making amends and
waiting patiently until a sufficient number of people grant him social

“Redemption is not a social decision; it is God’s alone,” Chiola says.

Starting point

Faith traditions have always valued forgiveness, citing God’s mercy
toward sinners and the possibility of reconciliation and, ultimately,

In Christianity, Christ’s parables about the unforgiving servant and
the prodigal son illustrate the centrality of forgiveness. In Judaism,
the high holy day of Yom Kippur itself atones for one’s sins against
God, who stands ready and eager to forgive. For Buddhists, the notions
of compassion and loving kindness compel one to forgive transgressions.

So what is the starting point for those seeking forgiveness?

“One needs to desire it,” says author and theologian Jill Raitt, who is
on the faculty at Fontbonne University in St. Louis. “If not, forget

The sincerity of the petition for forgiveness, says Springfield
psychologist Kirk Boyenga, “is between God and us. If the purpose is to
manipulate God (into forgiveness), it won’t work. But I can’t judge
someone else’s heart.”

“Forgiveness is always an act of God’s grace,” Chiola adds. “If a
person asks for forgiveness, from a Christian perspective, God grants

In Judaism, the offender must seek forgiveness from the wronged party.
If the offender is rebuffed three times, the sin falls upon the person
initially wronged, says Rabbi Michael Datz of Temple B’rith Sholom in

There are conditions, however. The offender must acknowledge the
transgression, identify it and express sincere remorse before seeking
forgiveness. The offender should then perform acts of penance — fasting
on Yom Kippur, for example, Datz says.

Michael Lang of the Springfield Baha’i community says people in his
faith are “told to strive to instantly forgive others. Mercy is an
attribute of God. If we have that thought of hate, we’re asked to have
a thought of greater love.”

Hinduism, explains Harish Bhatt of Springfield, is a tolerant religion
whose followers are willing to give transgressors the benefit of the
doubt. But God ultimately has the last word.

“If someone has done something wrong, God gives that person a chance to
do better in the next life, or that person might suffer in the next
life,” Bhatt says.

Bhatt decries the fact that forgiveness is an attribute of the weak.

“(Mohandas) Gandhi would forgive anybody for anything not because he
was a coward,” Bhatt says. “It’s only strong people who can forgive.”

The act of forgiving, Chiola says, goes through stages. And it isn’t without struggle.

“Forgiveness demands that I embrace my suffering and move through the
wound in order to thrive,” Chiola says. “Forgiveness does not forget
the injury, but it does transform it.”

It can happen

Where does this leave figures who have betrayed the public’s trust?

Some, like the Rev. Newman, applaud contrition while acknowledging there is still much work to do.


“Redemption is one step at a time,” Newman says. “While you’ll never
gain everyone’s acceptance, the important thing is that he has to be at
peace with himself.”


Maryam Mostoufi of the Islamic Society of Greater Springfield says
society has a stake in re-welcoming offenders and empowering them to
have better lives.

“You have the responsibility to change the environment, the culture in
which that person lives,” Mostoufi says. A society can only judge that
person’s behavior in the aftermath, she adds, to measure that person’s
sincerity of contrition.

Raitt, the Fontbonne professor, says the sacrament of reconciliation,
or confession, is important because there is a strong social component
to sin — cutting off that person from God, but also from the church

Seeking forgiveness from the public, however, “seems to me just to be
posturing,” says Holy Cross parish’s Laughery. “Instead of a blanket
‘pardon’ from a nameless public, a person seeking forgiveness must
identify the concrete individuals whom he or she has hurt.”

Only the one who was wronged can forgive the wrongdoer, Rabbi Datz adds
— no forgiveness by proxy. That’s why public displays of forgiveness
are “an insult to the memory of those who have been harmed,” he says.

“There’s no provision in society for forgiveness,” St. Frances
Cabrini’s Chiola says. “A person can be restored to society but not
forgiven (by society).”

The road back is well-paved, however.

In sermons, Newman says he often cites President Richard Nixon’s former
chief counsel, Charles Colson, who served a prison term for obstruction
of justice related to attempts to defame a government whistleblower.
Colson later founded Prison Fellowship, which seeks to rehabilitate
former prisoners.

And, Newman points out, who would have thought Kobe Bryant basketball
jerseys would sell in the aftermath of the sexual allegation charges
against the Los Angeles Lakers guard in 2003? (Charges against Bryant
were later dropped, and he remains one of the NBA’s top players.)

Michael Vick’s redemption as a person, says Sacred Heart-Griffin High
School football coach Ken Leonard, “has nothing to do with what he’s
accomplished as a football player. I tell my players, ‘Your value as a
man has nothing to do with football.’ I hope we’re forgiving (toward
Vick) not so much by what he could give us as an athlete, but what he
could as a potential role model or father.”

“Most people focus on redemption as society’s view of them,” Mostoufi
says. “(Vick) needs to be working on redemption before God.”

That public redemption, Mostoufi acknowledges, would realistically find
Vick working with police authorities against dogfighting. The Animal
Protective League in a statement encouraged Vick to use his celebrity
to show young people what he did was wrong.

If Vick is interested in making amends, “it’s important that he be
reconciled with the community,” Raitt says. “It restores a balance.”

“When there is true repentance — Godly sorrow — actions will go
hand-in-hand with behavior,” Newman says. “(Vick) can still rise above
(what’s in his past.) When you make mistakes, you don’t allow them to
hold you bondage the rest of your life.

“I still see him as a person, someone created in God’s image. I still see him as impacting the lives of others.”

Steven Spearie can be reached at

Thoughts on redemption

– In him we have redemption through his blood, the forgiveness of our
trespasses, according to the riches of his grace which he lavished upon
us. — Ephesians 1, 7-8

– They should rather pardon and overlook. Would you not love Allah to
forgive you? Allah is Ever-Forgiving, Most Merciful. — Qur’an 24:22

– Hide thy face from my sins, and blot out all my iniquities. Create in
me a clean heart, O God, and put a new and right spirit within me. —
Psalms 51, 9-10

– To understand everything is to forgive everything. — Buddha

– Forgiveness is the might of the mighty; forgiveness is sacrifice;
forgiveness is quiet of mind. — Mahabharata, Vana Parva, Section XXVIII

– For if you forgive others their trespasses, your heavenly Father will
also forgive you, but if you do not forgive others, neither will your
father forgive your trespasses. — Matthew 6:14

– I pray Thee by Him Who is the sovereign Lord of Names to write down
for me with the Pen of Thy bounty that which will enable me to draw
nigh unto Thee and will purge me from my trespasses, which have
intervened between me and Thy forgiveness and Thy pardon. — “Tablets of
Baha’ullah Revealed after the Kitab-i-Aqdas” (pgs. 24-25)


Blog PostCourtsForgivenessPrisonsRJ OfficeVictim Support
Support the cause

We've Been Restoring Justice for More Than 40 Years

Your donation helps Prison Fellowship International repair the harm caused by crime by emphasizing accountability, forgiveness, and making amends for prisoners and those affected by their actions. When victims, offenders, and community members meet to decide how to do that, the results are transformational.

Donate Now